READ THE STATEMENT · PLATFORMS
Airbnb Said It Takes Reports Like This “Seriously.” The Guest Caught the AI Photo Himself.
(A Tasmania host asked a French tourist for A$1,755 over a clogged toilet, using a photo Google’s detector found was made or edited with AI. Airbnb has since deactivated the listing.)
By Ethan Ward · Published Nov. 9, 2026 · Updated Nov. 12, 2026 · 4-minute read
In August and September, a French tourist named Alban stayed at two places in Hobart, Tasmania, run by a host called The A Family. When he left, he wrote a 1-star review.
Two days later the host asked him for A$1,755 through Airbnb: A$1,500 for “foreign object extraction” from a toilet and A$255 for cleaning. The claim came with a photo of a toilet overflowing onto the floor and two invoices.
Alban thought the photo was fake. He posted it online and ran it through an AI detector. When ABC News checked it with Google’s SynthID Detector, it found the photo had been made or edited with Google’s AI. Neither company on the invoices matched a real business, ABC News found. Airbnb rejected the claim. This is what it said.

ABC News’s story on the claim, with the photo the host submitted. Google’s SynthID Detector found the photo was made or edited with Google AI.
SCREENSHOT: ABC NEWS; IMAGE: SUPPLIED
THE STATEMENT · AIRBNB · NOV. 3, 2026 · ABC NEWS
A spokesman for Airbnb Australia and New Zealand, to ABC News:
“We take reports like this seriously … the guest has been fully refunded and will not be charged.” (1. The report came from the guest. Alban spotted the fake, posted it, and ran the check himself. Airbnb hasn’t said whether it checks photos in damage claims for AI.)
(2. “Fully refunded” was almost A$2,000 for both stays and tours he missed while fighting the claim, Alban told ABC News. He moved his flights home 10 days early, afraid he’d run out of money.)

Airbnb’s statement, as ABC News published it.
SCREENSHOT: ABC NEWS
Our notes
What happened to the host. Airbnb has deactivated the listing, said Ian Paterson, a communications manager for Airbnb in Australia and New Zealand. The A Family runs 12 listings in Tasmania and Victoria, ABC News reported. A host who gives Airbnb false or misleading information can have their account suspended or banned, the company told ABC News. Its rules for hosts already ban using AI to hide flaws or damage in listing photos.
The host’s side. The host didn’t respond to ABC News before publication. In a message to Alban, it said it wouldn’t have filed a claim if not for his “crazy retaliatory review,” and that it had “let many charges go” for guests who were straight with it. Its review called him “hostile and demanding” and didn’t mention a toilet.
How a claim works. A host asks for money through Airbnb’s Resolution Center, and the guest has 24 hours to respond. If the guest doesn’t pay, the host can bring in Airbnb, and a support agent decides using the host’s evidence and the guest’s reply. A guest who is charged has 60 days to appeal.
What the detector can’t do. Google’s detector looks for Google’s own AI watermark, which a few other companies have started using. A photo made with a tool that doesn’t carry it could pass.
What you can do
Take photos when you arrive and when you leave. Dated photos and video of every room are your evidence if a claim comes later.
Answer within 24 hours. Reply in the Resolution Center, say what you dispute, and attach your own photos. If you think the request is unfair, ask Airbnb’s Community Support team, open 24/7, to review it.
Check the invoices. Look up the business. In Australia, you can check a business’s number on the government’s ABN Lookup.
Check the photos. Upload a claim photo to Google’s Gemini app and ask whether Google’s AI made or edited it. A “no” doesn’t clear it.
Appeal if you’re charged. You have 60 days.
Get stories like this in one email a month.
Around the 1st, with one thing to act on before a deadline. Free to read. Unsubscribe any time.
How we reported this
This story is built on ABC News’s reporting by Jessica Black, Airbnb’s help pages, and Google’s, all linked above and checked Nov. 9, 2026. We asked Airbnb on Nov. 9 whether it checks photos in damage claims for AI and what it did about the host. On Nov. 12, it said it had deactivated the listing. Updated Nov. 12, 2026, with Airbnb’s response.
Rejected, suspended, or flagged for no reason? Tell me what happened.
The notice rarely says AI. It says “not selected” or “account suspended.” I read every tip myself.

