
IS THIS AI? · ACCUSED OF USING AI
Is This Night Sky Real? It Took 578 Photos and 45 Hours.
CALLED FAKE
(Our answer: Yes. Brendan Larsen stacked photos he took over Mount Taranaki, and the gaps in every satellite trail show how he shot them.)
By Ethan Ward · Published Nov. 9, 2026 · 3-minute read · Photo: Brendan Larsen / Instagram, shown for commentary

What people said it was
Brendan Larsen is an astrophotographer in New Plymouth, New Zealand. In mid-October he posted a picture of the night sky over Mount Taranaki, crossed by thousands of satellite trails. It drew about 15 million views on Facebook and 1 million on Instagram in a week, Stuff reported.
Most people reacted to the sky. Of about 10,000 comments on his Facebook page, he told The Guardian, nine in 10 said something like “Wow, beautiful photo, but horrifying, terrifying and really concerning about what’s happening to the night sky.”
Some thought it was too much to be real. The Guardian reported that some viewers dismissed it as AI, and ran the story under the headline that he’d been accused of using it. The Instagram comments we read were mostly praise. One person wrote just “Fake.” Another asked, “It can’t be real, is it?” Larsen answered, “it’s real.” A third guessed it right, “I’m guessing this is made by stacking 100s of frames of satellite tracks.”
Larsen saw the question coming. He filmed his process, expecting it, and his caption opens with the answer, “14K SATELLITE TRAILS! (NOT AI!)”
“AI generating software is becoming so good it is becoming difficult to tell AI images from real images … especially if you’re not familiar with the location or with astrophotography,” he told The Guardian. He called the doubts frustrating. Seeing people download his picture and remake it with AI, with obvious flaws, was exasperating, he said.

Comments on Larsen’s post, shown for commentary. We blurred the commenters’ names.
SCREENSHOT: INSTAGRAM
How we checked
Where it first appeared. On his own Instagram and Facebook accounts, starting in mid-October. He has posted it more than once. He sells prints and offers astrophotography coaching through his own site, and has photographed the night sky for about six years.
How he made it. One night in September he left his camera running for about two hours, taking eight-second photos with a two-second gap between them, 578 in all. Then he spent about 45 hours in Photoshop stacking them and erasing stars to bring out the satellites. His timelapse of the shoot runs with The Guardian’s story.
What the picture shows. Each satellite trail breaks into dashes. Every dash is one eight-second photo, and every gap is the two seconds the camera wasn’t shooting. “That’s why you get the gaps in the satellite trails,” he told Stuff.
Whether the numbers add up. About 25 satellites showed up in each photo. Across 578 photos, that’s about 14,450 trails, the estimate he posted. He estimates they came from about 1,400 satellites, each showing up in about 10 photos.
Who we asked. We asked Larsen what people said when they doubted it, and about the AI copies he’s seen.
It’s a real photograph, and a lot of work. The only AI in this story is in the copies other people made of it.
Check one yourself
Read the caption. Find the first post and the person who made it. Larsen’s caption says how he shot it, and he filmed the process.
Look at the details. Photos stacked from a camera repeat its rhythm, like the even gaps in these trails.
Know what a detector can tell you. Google’s Gemini app checks for Google’s AI watermark and, when a file carries them, Content Credentials that record how it was made. A “no” doesn’t mean another AI tool wasn’t used, and it can’t prove a picture is real.
Ask before you say it. If you think something is AI, ask the person who posted it how they made it.
Get stories like this in one email a month.
Around the 1st, with one thing to act on before a deadline. Free to read. Unsubscribe any time.
How we reported this
This story is built on Larsen’s own posts and reporting by The Guardian and Stuff, all linked above and checked Nov. 9, 2026. We asked Larsen through his site on Nov. 9 about the doubts and the AI copies. We’ll add his answer here when he replies.
Rejected, suspended, or flagged for no reason? Tell me what happened.
The notice rarely says AI. It says “not selected” or “account suspended.” I read every tip myself.

